Enrique Gutierrez

I do stuff

Houston? WTF (AlertThingy vs. Twhirl)

AlertThingy TwhirlOk… we, meaning me in this case, have a problem. I’m not really into jumping on the buzz and getting a scoop on a “story”, for me? That’s short-lived love for writing, yuck, but what’s going on today with the battle of the AIR apps is a little… well, crap.

I commented yesterday that via an imaginary friend on FriendFeed I was following my “with others” feed on Twitter within AlertThingy. I ended up deciding I didn’t really much like that, so I killed my imaginary friend “Others”… he died quickly and painlessly. Now I’m here with version 1.2 of AlertThingy that allows me to Tweet from it… Ok, this is handy, cause I can just use Twitter as I always have: receive notifications I track on my phone, tweet when I find something useful or random to share, and reply to others when I’m replied to - this method keeps Twitter from being constantly paid attention to, and keeps my day going smooth as butter.

Twhirl… “We’re now compatible with FriendFeed” in version 0.7.9 - I think… Awesome. Now when I want to crack out on Twitter I can close AlertThingy, crack open Twhirl, and have both in one window just going awesome! o_O Not the case? Two windows… I hate making assumptions about things before using them.

Anyway, I can see the awesome in having two windows (one for Twitter, one for FriendFeed) in Twhirl, as an option maybe… but otherwise, it’s the same as having AlertThingy open… Now I have to have them all open to examine which one I think is going to be more intuitive for me to simply “use” without thinking about it, a funny paradox in and of itself. Sucks.

Both apps have good points and bad. Twhirl wasn’t made for FriendFeed, and it sort of shows: requiring users to select search to search, the lookup feature is … well, unnecessary, really, and I can’t Tweet from this window, so I need to open the other if I want to share something, which would release the Twitter bug while I’m trying a minor distraction for myself for a few seconds via a Twitter post. (That sells me on AlertThingy)

AlertThingy on the other hand only shows me tweets from people on my FriendFeed, rightfully so. Yes, I could resurrect “Others” from the dead, but then I’m just reading tweets all day in AlertThingy… bastards! So here’s what I get to do now, I guess, keep’m both - f**k it.

share:
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • TwitThis
  • Propeller
  • del.icio.us
  • Ma.gnolia
  • Google
  • Live
  • Facebook
  • Furl
  • Technorati
  • Mixx

2 Comments so far

  1. Dan April 17th, 2008 10:29 am

    Do what I do.

    Wait for the dust to settle - choose last man standing. I’m using twitterific and a web browser until a winner emerges.

    Jumping on the bandwagon = trendy = stupid

  2. admin April 17th, 2008 10:38 am

    I agree. Problem being. I LOVE AIR apps…and kind of got sold on using Twhirl for Twitter, and actually like it. I think I’m going to “ignore” the fact that it can do FriendFeed. AlertThingy is simple and lightweight… and I can easily ignore the fact that it can Tweet… works for me for now…

Leave a reply

retaggr
  boinkme